Was Carly Smithson voted off American Idol because she sang "Jesus Christ Superstar," the Andrew Lloyd Webber headliner that's offensive to some Christians, who undoubtedly make up a huge portion of the losers who dial 866 numbers? MAYBE! Not even her Irish roots could save her. (The terrible Kristy Lee Cook stayed on another week after singing "God Bless the U.S.A.") Nevermind that the first inkling the same voting bloc gets about David Archuleta's sessuality will also have him canned, unless the OMG HE'S SOOOOO CUTE factor weighs heavier.