The art director of Glamour has us stumped.

We get that thin is in and everything, but why would you thin out America Ferrera? Her whole career, from Real Women Have Curves to Ugly Betty is based on her not being skinny. A major plot of point of The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants was the size of her ass. If the Men’s Fitness editor was called out for adding muscle to a professional athlete, don’t you think that people would be able to tell that pounds were digitally shaved off of America Ferrera?

It seems impossible, but this cover is not even worthy of a feature about 39 sexy things to do with hair.