Open Letter to Whiny Critics: Let Kids Be Fat On Television
They were just going to be fat off television, anyway
 


With American children and their goddamn obesity epidemic, it's only reasonable to assume that sooner or later the traditional TV-repellent overweight tykes would start appearing on your favorite shows. Weeds has Cylia's daughter Isabella, the chunky wise beyond her years proto-lesbian. Arrested Development had the curvy Maebe played by Alia Shawkat, who was on the receiving end of Michael Cera's unrequited lust. Nothing wrong with normal-sized children on TV, in fact this is a good trend! But what about when TV characters start treating overweight children without kid gloves, much the way the fat kids are treated in school?

On this season of Desperate Housewives, Gabrielle's daughter is constantly berated for being overweight, and now some viewers are fearing for the self-esteem of the actress playing little Juanita Solice.

"(the spokespeople) assured us that producers have been taking precautions from the get-go. For instance, they made a conscious effort to hire an older actress to play the part. Madison is seven, playing a four-year-old.
Also, Madison is never present during scenes featuring the adult characters talking about her weight."

That is entirely off the mark. Seven years old is still a child, and at that age you're old enough to realize that you're being made fun of. But what's the solution, only hire skinny child actors and put them in fat suits, like Ryan Reynolds in Just Friends? Let's see how fast child advocacy groups and other associations would begin to gripe about how no overweight actresses get roles in Hollywood.

Do kids know what they are getting into at that age, by exposing themselves to on-air criticism about their bodies? Maybe, maybe not. Perhaps the answer is to create more positive body-image dialogue in the shows, but that wouldn't necessarily be true to life either.

Tricky dilemma, but critics whining about the poor plight of these actors who are actually managing to get work will just force producers to cut these characters from the scripts all-together to appease the ratings gods. And then, what? Back to Monica in the fat suit and every family on television having anorexically-small children.

Fark Facebook Digg StumbleUpon Del.icio.us Reddit
Comments (4)

No. 1 · FatNSassy

It is not just damaging to the child actors. When kids see adults making fun of fat kids, it legitimizes it. Of course, so much of t.v. today is bought and paid for by sponsors. So I wouldn't be surprised if that story line was not influenced by some weight loss sponsor who wants to increase business and kids are their next target. After all, weight obsession is more important to the power-elite than ever in a bad economy! It is one way billions get transferred from the middle class to corporations each year.

Posted: Oct 19, 2008 at 5:05 pm · @Reply · [Flag?]
No. 2 · JP

Um, here's a radical solution: don't berate, make fun of, or otherwise insult fat children, period. It boggles the mind that a fat child character on any show would be "constantly berated," and that this phenomena is presented as something which naturally follows… The child is fat, therefore of course she is constantly berated by her parents and other characters on the show for her weight. It's appalling.

Posted: Oct 24, 2008 at 12:58 am · @Reply · [Flag?]
No. 3 · Sarah

Insulting fat kids is wrong, but pretending that their obesity is not a problem is wrong too, one that could end up cutting their lives short by several decades. And for all the attention that anorexia gets, there are far more children out there with serious weight problems. Kudos to Desperate Housewives for at least addressing this.

Posted: Dec 8, 2008 at 1:47 am · @Reply · [Flag?]
No. 4 · Joey

LOL FAT LITTLE MEXICAN

Posted: Jan 19, 2009 at 2:51 am · @Reply · [Flag?]
Leave a Comment

It's easier to leave comments when you register for an account. It's quick.

Already have an account? Then log in!

NEW: You can add images to your comment by clicking here and entering the URL of the picture.

 
Scroll Posts
Jossip Home | Advertise | Copyright 2009 Jossip Initiatives