While Ashton Kutcher might think he’s punking the celebrity press with spam-happy Pop Fiction, most celebrity weekly editors say his stunts are fooling them.

After all, the tabloids have eyes and ears everywhere; you think J. Lo goes on vacation without her handlers first checking with Larry Hackett to see if it’s okay?

So while they might run photos of Paris Hilton and her “shaman,” they also report that the whole thing is a stunt. Luckily those celebrity blogs don’t have the resources of an always-accurate tabloid.