We always liked Two-A-Days, MTV’s reality TV show about high school football players in Alabama. But now we realize the show could have been even better if they had only followed Coach Propst more.

The tough love coach will resign at the end of the football season after it was revealed that his staff changed grades, spied on rival teams and used ineligible players. Unrelated to football, but still quite juicy: Propst had carried on an affair in another town and had an illegitimate child.

For some reason all this fun led to the canceling of the third season of Two-A-Days. With a writers’ strike looming, MTV must be kicking itself for walking away from such great unscripted drama.