When exploring the realm of former boy-banders, the question of "gay or closeted" tends to come up with alarming frequency. Which is why we're not exactly surprised by a blind item regarding a former boy-bander who was terrified of being photographed with his same-sex humpbuddy

In fact, this morning's Whodunit actually has us scratching our heads trying to figure out which guys-only crooner isn't a fan of man-to-man defense.

So which new kid on the block isn't quite ready to wave bye-bye-bye to straightdom? Which hotstepping homo hasn't yet declared "I want it that way" in reference to his en fuego (male) Spanish escort? Naturally, we're stumped, but if you think you've got the scoop, let us know Whodunit.

Which still-closeted former boy-bander was making sure nobody got pictures of him with his handsome Spanish escort at a recent European charity event?